
В визуальном исследовании рассмотрены основные методы работы с речевыми актами и меньшими структурами языка: материализация, пересборка, изобретение, инкорпорация. Анализ демонстрирует, как язык становится материалом, из которого строится высказывание, выходящее за пределы обычной речи.

Вопрос о трансформации языка в искусстве напрямую связан с динамикой развития культуры, проблематиками власти и идентичности. Язык не нейтрален: в нём заложена история колонизации и иерархии. Как говорит Белл Хукс (белл хукс), «язык — это также пространство борьбы», где угнетённые вынуждены отстаивать право на язык.


В этой идее отражен постколониальный сдвиг в восприятии языка: та же ри, что навязывалась империями как средство подавления, сегодня может быть переосмыслена и превращена в орудие сопротивления и утверждения независимости.


Для автора исследования тема трансформации языка несёт личный характер, связанный с феноменом казахско- русского двуязычия. Казахстан — постколониальное пространство, в котором на протяжении десятков лет русский преобладал в публичных сферах, в то время как казахский вытеснялся в сельский обиход.


Maude Léonard-Contant at Kunsthaus Baselland, Switzerland // Daily Lazy — URL https://daily-lazy.com/2022/10/maude-leonard-contant-at-kunsthaus-baselland-switzerland.html
Dulce Soledad Ibarra (viewing room) // UTA Artist Space — URL https://www.utaartistspace.com/viewing-
rooms/dulce-soledad-ibarra/
Qit Qat Qa // Slavs and Tatars — URL https://www.slavsandtatars.com/cycles/language-arts/qit-qat-qa
(дата обращения: 12.09.2025).
The Naughty Nasals // Slavs and Tatars — URL https://www.slavsandtatars.com/cycles/language-arts/
the-naughty-nasals
(дата обращения: 13.09.2025).
Qatalogue // Slavs and Tatars — URL https://www.slavsandtatars.com/cycles/language-arts/qatalogue
(дата обращения: 14.09.2025).
Kin A. Brotes / Anna Kin — URL https://anjakin.com/
(дата обращения: 15.09.2025).
Liu Jianhua: Collected Letters // Asian Art Museum — URL https://exhibitions.asianart.org/exhibitions/
liu-jianhua-collected-letters/
(дата обращения: 16.09.2025).
Материал раздела Art // Sobaka.ru — URL https://www.sobaka.ru/entertainment/art/115156
(дата обращения: 17.09.2025).
John Smith (artist page) // Contemporary Art Library — URL https://www.contemporaryartlibrary.org/artist/
john-smith-3500
(дата обращения: 18.09.2025).
Artwork (collection page) // Guggenheim Museum — URL https://www.guggenheim.org/artwork/10379
(дата обращения: 19.09.2025).
Trouble // Art Institute of Chicago — URL https://www.artic.edu/artworks/198567/trouble
(дата обращения: 20.09.2025).
Untitled (Double Trouble) // Sotheby’s — URL https://www.sothebys.com/en/buy/auction/2024/
contemporary-evening-auction/untitled-double-trouble
(дата обращения: 21.09.2025).
Mathieu Tremblin: Tag Clouds — graffiti art, internet font // designboom — URL https://www.designboom.com/
art/mathieu-tremblin-tag-clouds-graffiti-art-internet-font-26.07.2016/
(дата обращения: 22.09.2025).
Mathieu Tremblin: Tag Clouds // It’s Nice That — URL https://www.itsnicethat.com/articles/mathieu-tremblin-
tag-clouds-26-07-16
(дата обращения: 23.09.2025).
artistprofile.com.au/wp-content/gallery/emily-floyd/workshop.jpg
content.ngv.vic.gov.au/col-images/api/EXHI026688/1920
tizianacontino.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/07/A-1024×726.jpg
tizianacontino.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/07/B-1024×726.jpg
tizianacontino.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/07/C_detail_1-1024×768.jpg
tizianacontino.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/07/D_detail_1-1024×768.jpg
tizianacontino.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/07/G_detail_1-1024×768.jpg
tomphillips.co.uk/images/stories/sculpture/Wittgensteins-Trap-1500.jpg
tomphillips.co.uk/images/stories/sculpture/wittgenstein-trap_detail_1000.
jpg
images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6565366f16f3431c6a5c17
30/9238a7f2-6876-4862-b6c6-811d9eb7641b/9thtoolympic_intall9.
jpg? format=1500w
images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6565366f16f3431c6a5c17
30/1550c29c-6bf8-4e07-abc3-1bbbdb65c48a/9thtoolympic_intall8.
jpg? format=1500w
images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6565366f16f3431c6a
5c1730/46979172-291a-4edb-91de-129e1b47508c/9thtoolympic_intall5.
jpg? format=1500w
images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6565366f16f3431c6a
5c1730/46979172-291a-4edb-91de-129e1b47508c/9thtoolympic_intall5.
jpg? format=1500w
slavsandtatars.com/site/assets/files/1168/dsc0064_csw_st.1024×0.jpg
slavsandtatars.com/site/assets/files/1168/dsc0059_csw_st.1024×0.jpg
slavsandtatars.com/site/assets/files/1164/qitqatqakitab_
longleggedlinguistics_spacepythagorion_2013_samos.480×0.jpg
slavsandtatars.com/site/assets/files/2523/rst8988b.1360×0.jpg
freight.cargo.site/w/1350/i/a00482828455fe535c48e96b53132da978ec4b
333347fe7da9bf4efcc27ee793/-Hotel-Continental-2025-25.jpg
freight.cargo.site/t/original/i/a28096cff9a108ad092ea2142c8c35a6f1fc924
8247b9ddab8e3b0a15e2ec79c/-Hotel-Continental-2025-29.jpg
freight.cargo.site/t/original/i/d45136366df71c2ca870464733d34a6985cad5
c991234da46c1dd32f65cece67/-Hotel-Continental-2025-30.jpg
freight.cargo.site/t/original/i/a421167c8b94db295e6718ef4fb9bb6abbfaa87
c69088cf47839876a1c380df9/-Hotel-Continental-2025-42.jpg
freight.cargo.site/t/original/i/a00482828455fe535c48e96b53132da978ec4
b333347fe7da9bf4efcc27ee793/-Hotel-Continental-2025-25.jpg
freight.cargo.site/t/original/i/9e84082778aa798056323c08a06533bb763ac
36f9ebacec1e4b72bdbbfe81704/-Hotel-Continental-2025-41.jpg
liujianhua.net/Uploads/WorksImgFile/WorkBigImgFi
le/20170423/20170423144107_3360.jpg
mgm-website-production.oss-cn-hongkong.aliyuncs.com/uploads/2021/11/
liu-jianhua.jpg
liujianhua.net/Uploads/KindEditorUpload/KindEditorUploadImag
es/20210324/20210324173044_4113.jpg
liujianhua.net/Uploads/KindEditorUpload/KindEditorUploadImag
es/20210324/20210324173114_2884.jpg
liujianhua.net/Uploads/KindEditorUpload/KindEditorUploadImag
es/20210324/20210324173201_1505.jpg
metronews.ru/userfiles/materials/160/1602621/858×540_660ca63b.jpg
metronews.ru/userfiles/materials/160/1602623/858×540_8802c717.jpg
pics.livejournal.com/mamaradeona/20211405/653253/653253_600.jpg
static.sobaka.ru/images/image/01/32/15/74/_normal.jpg? v=1599510310
static.sobaka.ru/images/image/01/32/15/75/_normal.jpg? v=1599510324
static.sobaka.ru/images/image/01/32/15/76/_normal.jpg? v=1599510334
static.sobaka.ru/images/image/01/32/12/54/_normal.jpeg? v=1599491645
jaumeplensa.com/gestorPlensa/images/entradas/entrada-40/117-Tempesta.
jpg
googleusercontent.com/proxy/9m_ziXBuFC8HUvqiFZlaIHMEykXS3iBilox0
SHp5g1qgooBrg1IEgMvS8S4hUW7VkSdlEMvCzOfYQUYRx0vSt-a83RFFIzu3-
oujJu78gdTuxWTBMCX2Nsu1Q
encrypted-tbn0.gstatic.com/images? q=tbn: ANd9GcSPMzYRCEKvN7X
km5-kEMSomoqJmnQmuMRbCtadnJMYZUQVH-5XC-Jdwuv--GcmisSc2-
U& usqp=CAU
encrypted-tbn0.gstatic.com/images? q=tbn: ANd9GcT12pBjjt0V_rqX986N4Eu
wbFCPiw1SHOXyMAHYDKQ68h_JFD7DJPR_tfzczvoF6jdxNe8& usqp=CAU
rodrigomoreira.com.br/wp-content/uploads/2017/06/rodrigomoreira_
vocabulary_still03.jpg
rodrigomoreira.com.br/wp-content/uploads/2017/06/rodrigomoreira_
vocabulary_still04.jpg
rodrigomoreira.com.br/wp-content/uploads/2017/06/rodrigomoreira_
vocabulary_still02.jpg
rodrigomoreira.com.br/wp-content/uploads/2017/06/rodrigomoreira_
vocabulary_still01-1.jpg
lozano-hemmer.com/image_sets/cloud_display/manchester_2019/cloud_
display_manchester_2019_my_505A6460.jpg
lozano-hemmer.com/image_sets/cloud_display/manchester_2019/cloud_
display_manchester_2019_my_505A6776.jpg
lozano-hemmer.com/image_sets/cloud_display/manchester_2019/cloud_
display_manchester_2019_my_505A6793.jpg
lozano-hemmer.com/image_sets/cloud_display/manchester_2019/cloud_
display_manchester_2019_my_505A6804.jpg
lozano-hemmer.com/image_sets/cloud_display/manchester_2019/cloud_
display_manchester_2019_my_505A6805.jpg
lozano-hemmer.com/image_sets/cloud_display/manchester_2019/cloud_
display_manchester_2019_my_505A6961.jpg
lozano-hemmer.com/image_sets/cloud_display/manchester_2019/cloud_
display_manchester_2019_my_505A6969.jpg
lozano-hemmer.com/image_sets/cloud_display/manchester_2019/cloud_
display_manchester_2019_my_505A7016.jpg
lozano-hemmer.com/image_sets/cloud_display/manchester_2019/cloud_
display_manchester_2019_my_505A7017.jpg
lozano-hemmer.com/image_sets/cloud_display/manchester_2019/cloud_
display_manchester_2019_my_505A7033.jpg
lozano-hemmer.com/image_sets/cloud_display/manchester_2019/cloud_
display_manchester_2019_my_505A7041.jpg
images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/5f176b6498df463c0e
92de9e/1601786333160-V4NH2C0WB4T1UC7Z2MD0/NinaG+1_
This+is+written+in+Farsi_2018.jpg? format=1000w
images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/5f176b6498df463c0e92de
9e/1601786335704-DGG7DPF3JV8NZWFAISLM/NinaG+4_This+is+written+fr
om+righ+to+left_2018.jpg? format=1000w
creapills.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/05/mathieu-tremblin-tag-clouds-
graffitis-typographies-lisibles-18-760×651.jpeg
creapills.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/05/mathieu-tremblin-tag-clouds-
graffitis-typographies-lisibles-2-760×566.jpeg
creapills.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/05/mathieu-tremblin-tag-clouds-
graffitis-typographies-lisibles-3-760×566.jpeg
creapills.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/05/mathieu-tremblin-tag-clouds-
graffitis-typographies-lisibles-4-760×566.jpeg
creapills.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/05/mathieu-tremblin-tag-clouds-
graffitis-typographies-lisibles-5-760×566.jpeg
creapills.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/05/mathieu-tremblin-tag-clouds-
graffitis-typographies-lisibles-6-760×566.jpeg
vimeo.com/213489558? fl=pl& fe=sh
contemporaryartlibrary.org/store/image/108830/imagefile/original_
jpeg-faec3cc40a0b552be037aacc0f1928ba.jpg
contemporaryartlibrary.org/store/image/108835/imagefile/original_
jpeg-63e4e3b1c5d6c0822258ec37b72e9f24.jpg
contemporaryartlibrary.org/store/image/108836/imagefile/original_
jpeg-a14bf3fb25b2c37e7dacae00cabc51cf.jpg
contemporaryartlibrary.org/store/image/108826/imagefile/original_
jpeg-1e38fffa1446495ef1323dc3d8b9faa9.jpg
contemporaryartlibrary.org/store/image/108817/imagefile/original_jpeg-
65d07d6bbf07dcaf66a6a748ac7bf1cc.jpg
contemporaryartlibrary.org/store/image/108808/imagefile/original_
jpeg-55e5fd9d5a04a1c4ea2c60d6578c4be9.jpg
images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/5f176b6498df463c0e92d
e9e/1601868128118-YNTQ42JSB42VPQPIXWOE/SorokinaK_1_2020.
jpg? format=1000w
images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/5f176b6498df463c0e92d
e9e/1601868268227-QZ4WJ8IDLLUJVIZMZ48O/SorokinaK_3_2020.
jpg? format=1000w
images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/5f176b6498df463c0e92de
9e/1601868319610-ND870NHJQOL06Q2Q2EAC/SorokinaK_5_2020.
jpg? format=1000w
images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/5f176b6498df463c0e92d
e9e/1601868187215-RV4PZL9DSU7J40PBBSRP/SorokinaK_2_2020.
jpg? format=1000w
store/adel-glinomeska/tproduct/181168130871-erudit
babibadalov.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/06/img-6710.jpg? w=768
aspangallery.com/images/covers/exhibition/74/wide_prtrts-035.jpg
slavsandtatars.com/site/assets/files/1147/ooops_2013-1.1024×0.jpg
sothebys-md.brightspotcdn.com/dims4/default/70bdc0f/2147483647/
strip/true/crop/2500×3442+0+0/resize/2048×2820! /quality/90/? url=http://
sothebys-brightspot.s3.amazonaws.com/media-desk/b6/48/35e28ee8428a
b067f48367660e1e/n11424-cz66k-t1-02.jpg
tomphillips.co.uk/images/stories/sculpture/cloo1750.jpg
31.08.2024-at-1.37.11-PM_1444.png
31.08.2024-at-1.38.06-PM_1444.png
dariairincheeva.com/Forced-Omission
media.voog.com/0000/0048/1769/photos/41_2009reformer150.jpg
media.voog.com/0000/0048/1769/photos/2_2013_47Catherine.jpg
artsy.net/artwork/kay-rosen-hi
staticflickr.com/5006/5305643481_734e495a25_b.jpg
kayrosen.com/art/090125-spring.jpg
guggenheim.org/wp-content/uploads/09.09.2020/2001.177_ph_web.jpg
encrypted-tbn0.gstatic.com/images? q=tbn: ANd9GcSJZazrAcnghGz8iOvgBd
Cx6lVBhDaId_H_oA& s
media.hauserwirth.com/m/c0e5944410be22b6/original/vip-30182.jpg
media.mutualart.com/Images/2015_04/26/14/143540914/2b1a83ef-de8e-
4f8f-a5e5-ef2a69e49103_570.Jpeg
kayrosen.com/art/2014backtrack.jpg
bynder-public-eu-central-1.s3.amazonaws.com/media/7F8951FF-19D4-
45D4-B982D6125B7E7BD3/7F73C4C0-92EF-4C87-82455AD5CE2C7CCD/
webimage-26BC5DF6-F947-43CB-B85D1AEC97AA0E31.jpg
bynder-public-eu-central-1.s3.amazonaws.com/media/7F8951FF-19D4-
45D4-B982D6125B7E7BD3/E5A691C2-74BF-4F17-8DD6A2AF7E6C18A0/
webimage-394EDB79-CB56-40D3-A60F8E7CC39959F9.jpg
staticflickr.com/65535/25262874720_fab70db75c_b.jpg
artnet.com/WebServices/images/ll00316lldFVYGFgJuB82CfDrCWvaHBOcYe
UC/svetlana-kopystiansky-seascape.jpg
staticflickr.com/3716/13192279093_b6da202a34_b.jpg
tomphillips.co.uk/images/stories/humument/tp_intro/massmoca_
opening_750.jpg
tomphillips.co.uk/images/stories/humument/tp_intro/p4_Humument_v2_750.
jpg
tomphillips.co.uk/images/stories/humument/tp_intro/p132_Humument_
v1_750.jpg
Humument_1967_750.jpg
images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/59cc690fcf81e
0b2a21215aa/1553194872887-ROYL7GDKFCKS7M7T8O4F/
JMB+il+pleut+negro+med+res.jpg? format=1500w
22slides.com/jchun/score-for-unlanguaging-0810-web-3171.jpg? f=webp
& w=1000& s=682e08e3ea0e7bd688f68b30f48a4248
22slides.com/jchun/scoreforunlanguaging010622-web-3149.jpg? f=webp
& w=1500& s=73ece48508f2539ab89014902c3f86b0
22slides.com/jchun/jec-1006-web-9642.jpg? f=webp& w=1116& s=2https://
22slides.com/jchun/jessechun-score1-gallerytpw-7553.jpg? f=webp& w=9
16& s=0d613e5e632ba44a773738c88ba098fd
artlogic-res.cloudinary.com/w_2400, h_2400, c_limit, f_auto, fl_lossy, q_auto/
artlogicstorage/alexandergray/images/view/e371f8c9e2bc4c70d4db032e6
df6a8f6j/alexandergrayassociates-glenn-ligon-notes-on-the-prelude-2012.
jpg
shopify.com/s/files/1/0192/3860/files/2018_10_GL_TDG-NAPLES_ph-F-
Squeglia-Grafiluce-crop_1200.jpg
guggenheim.org/wp-content/uploads/09.09.2020/2001.177_ph_web.jpg
media.mutualart.com/Images//2024_04/29/23/231329402/glenn-ligon-
debris-field--red---1-237P7.Jpeg
d2u3kfwd92fzu7.cloudfront.net/catalog/artwork/gallery/1297/TDA10602-
image.jpg
crousel.com/media/uploads/news/2019/03/web/GLS_Study-for-Debris-
Field-11_2018_10693.jpg
slavsandtatars.com/site/assets/files/1145/tonguetwisther_
longleggedlinguistics_spacepythagorion_2013_samos_3.480×0.jpg
slavsandtatars.com/site/assets/files/1145/a-place-of-our-time-19.1360×0.
jpg
images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/59cc690fcf81e0b2a21
215aa/1517957439688-TW6EKR5Y140Y7U7RN94X/1301_JMB-22.
jpg? format=1500w
lozano-hemmer.com/image_sets/translation_stream/abu_dhabi_2023/
translation_stream_abu_dhabi_2023_rlh_003.jpg
lozano-hemmer.com/image_sets/translation_stream/abu_dhabi_2023/
translation_stream_abu_dhabi_2023_rlh_004.jpg
lozano-hemmer.com/image_sets/translation_stream/abu_dhabi_2023/
translation_stream_abu_dhabi_2023_lg_003.jpg
lozano-hemmer.com/image_sets/translation_stream/al_ain_2025/
translation_stream_al_ain_2025_dct_4.jpg
lozano-hemmer.com/image_sets/encodedecode/montreal_2020/encode_
decode_montreal_2020_ml_000341.jpg
lozano-hemmer.com/image_sets/encodedecode/montreal_2020/encode_
decode_montreal_2020_ml_000402.jpg
lozano-hemmer.com/image_sets/encodedecode/montreal_2020/encode_
decode_montreal_2020_ml_000650.jpg
lozano-hemmer.com/image_sets/encodedecode/montreal_2020/encode_
decode_montreal_2020_ml_000567.jpg
dza2a2ql7zktf.cloudfront.net/binaries-cdn/dqzqcuqf9/image/upload/c_
fill, q_auto, dpr_1.0, f_auto, w_auto/v1574941940/mfp-fe-artworks/
owoe6obf7jryd33rhxzu.jpg
tomphillips.co.uk/images/stories/paintings/HereExemp_72_2.jpg
kayrosen.com/art/2016stilllife.jpg
xubing.com/Uploads/Source/Image/20230118/20230118165135_5386.jpg
xubing.com/Uploads/Source/Image/20230118/20230118165323_9940.jpg
xubing.com/Uploads/Source/Image/20230118/20230118165406_2475.jpg
xubing.com/Uploads/Source/Image/20230118/20230118165437_5105.jpg
xubing.com/Uploads/Source/Image/20230118/20230118165500_5485.jpg